THE CASE OF THE TRAIN MURDER….

……ASHE MURDER CASE

BY

RANDOR GUY

-2-

     A search of the dead assailant’s residence brought out more letters which threw more light on the conspiracy. Those mentioned one Arumugham Pillai who had been in touch with Vanchi. He was traced and the British Indian Police got out of this weak- kneed man loads of information. Later he was taken as approver. Another man Somasundaram was also traced and he too cracked at the seams and let out a good heap of sawdust inside. He too turned approver.

The cops did not leave a single stone unturned. Searches were made all over South India and the root of it all pointed to Punditry, a port town on the Bay of Bengal, then part of French territory beyond the pale of British India. As the Public Prosecutor of Madras High Court, C.F. Napier commented later during the trial, '' the extraordinary way in which the town of Pondicherry seems to permeate this case", this historic town of Dupleix and Anandarangam Pillai played a significant role in the fight for Indian Freedom.

Pondicherry being alien French territory proved a haven for Indian revolutionaries hounded and hunted by the British Indian Police. The friendly quiet beautiful small town gave political asylum to great freedom  fighters like Aurobindo Ghosh, V.V. S. Iyer, a lawyer turned rebel who trained men in armed combat and guerrilla warfare, and Mahakavi Subramania Bharathiar, the great rebel poet of India whose works in Tamil were banned by the British Indian Government. Many publications in English and Tamil were produced here and circulated secretly in British Indian territory in spite of the ban on them. Indeed Pondicherry was a veritable factory of patriotic fervor.

Soon the police rounded up as many as fourteen men who were charged with various offences under the Indian Penal Code like murder, waging war against the King-Emperor of India, and criminal conspiracy. The accused were the following...) Neelakanta, alias Brahmachari, a Brahmin youth of twenty one, a journalist, fiery patriot and person of considerable persuasive skills and charm, and the leader of a conspiracy to murder Ashe, according to the police)...2) Sankarakrishna Iyer, a young farmer ... 3) Madathukadai Chidambaram Pillai (no relation of VOC), a green-grocer ... 4) Muthukumarasami Pillai, a pot vendor in his forties…5) Subbaiah Pillai, a lawyer’s clerk... 6) Jagannatha Ayyangar, a young cook... 7) Harihara Iyer, a young merchant... 8) Bapu Pillai, a farmer... . 9) V. Desikachari, a merchant... 10) Vembu Iyer, a cook11) Savadi Arunachalam, Pillai, a farmer... 12) Alagappa Pillai, a teen-aged farmer... 13) ‘Vande MatharamSubramania Iyer, a schoolmaster, and 14) Pichumani Iyer, a cook.

Altogether a motley crowd of men mostly in their twenties of different professions and castes but all of them had something in common. They were all patriots burning with desire and thirst for freedom, their muscles and all set to drive out the Imperialistic British from India.

In the ordinary course this case would have been tried by the District and Sessions Judge at Tinnevelly. But in view of its political importance and the murder victim being a Britisher and an ICS Officer at that, the case was sent up to the High Court at Madras. Here a Full Bench of three judges consisting of Sir Arnold White, then the Chief Justice of Madras,  tried it, as a special case  along with  Justice Ayling, and Mr. Justice C. Sankaran Nair (later Sir C. Sankaran Nair). The case not surprisingly attracted attention all over India and even beyond achieving the status of a ‘cause celebre’.

C. F. Napier, Public Prosecutor assisted by T. Richmond and A. Sundara Sastrigal appeared for the Crown, while a glittering array of eminent Madras lawyers defended the accused. Neelakanta was the defended by a British Barrister, J.C. Adam. Another Barrister, a brilliant and mercurial Indian, a great patriot and future leader who gave away his wealth and all for his native land, Tanguturi Prakasam appeared for Sankarakrishna and three other accused.

(In later years T. Prakasam known as ' Andhra Kesari'- the Lion of Andhra- occupied several high positions in South India as Chief Minister of Madras, and Andhra Pradesh, Central minister at Delhi and others. He began as pleader in Rajamundry now in Andhra Pradesh where he quickly scaled to the top. Realizing that the District Headquarters town was too small an arena for a person of his brilliance and talents he went to England and qualified him as Barrister. Back home he set up practice at Madras where he soon made a mark and moved to the forefront of the Bar. Sadly in recent years this great patriot and warm human soul has been sidelined.)

M. D. Devadoss (later Mr. Justice Devadoss), J. L. Rozario, B. Narasimha Rao, T. M. Krishnaswami Iyer (a future leader of the Madras bar and later, sometime Chief Justice of the Travancore High Court. He was also a great savant of Hindu religious lore.), L. A. Govindaraghava Iyer, S. T. Srinivasagopalachari, (a high-ranking Freemason, an eminent epigraphist and numismatist with a fabulous collection of ancient coins of solid gold!) and V. Ryru Nambiar held the brief for the other accused.

(To be continued)